Firmware 10 on System Red PCB 10.5 - firmware bug ???

[mmlightning]

Hello,

I installed the new firmware on my PCB 10.5 controller for System red. The PCB was manufactured according to schematic and Eagle-File:https://docs.lightningmaps.org/files/hardware/red/PCB_10_5.brd

The firmware did not work properly as the PCB-ID was not detectected correctly. It turned out that PCB 10.5 has a different coding then described.

Description according to the hardware reference in TablePCB Controller Ids:
 https://docs.lightningmaps.org/hardware/...system-red 

Id PCB System PD10 PD11 PD3 PD1 Offset
2 10.5   RED      -        +        -       -      0

but it turned out that actually Coding of PCB 10.4 and PCB 10.5 is different, PCB10.5 has the following coding:
Id PCB System PD10 PD11 PD3 PD1 Offset
? 10.5  RED      +        +        -       -       0

this can also be seen in the schematic of PCB 10.5,  so PD10 has a high level +5V  instead of GND like PCB 10.4.

I did cut off pin PD10 from the controller-board and now all is working; PCB 10.5 is detected as PCB10.4 now

... but it seems that there is a firmware bug in 10 RED ???? This potentially could affect several stations, as station list has decreased since new firmware is out

[Tobi]

Sorry for my late reply after 8 months. I checked the firmware and every documentation I could find and I think there could be only this explanation: On the original PCB 10.5 the PCB id was accidentally the same as 10.4. The downloadable schematics/layout must have been altered and use the correct PCB id 3. It seems those PCBs were never produced/shipped by Egon, so I never added the id to the firmware.

I will add id 3 to the next firmware so the hardware doesn't have to be modified.

@mmlightning: Thanks a lot for the hint!